All Reviews
Andrew Rushlow
Edited 2 years agoI absolutely love this place for the creativity and the awesome food. I talked with the cook and it seems like he loves what he does. The burgers are seared to perfection and the taste is just so freaking good. I can’t wait to come back for another round because these guys know what they’re doing. Great food great service and very clean! Keep up the hard work guys!
Aaron Merritt
2 years agoEh, edible food. Nice lady took our order. While I feel like it was fine for a one stop taste test and while the prices were fairly consistent with the area, the food didn't match the typical fair. More reminded me of a high school cafeteria that didn't know how to cook very well, so they just soak everything in grease, too much toppings and sauces. I'm all for greasy messy food, but it should taste worth it and to me, it just wasn't. Burger meat had that "off" rubbery, over cooked flavor, the buns were dense, the ranch was actually ranch flavored mayonnaise, the chicken tenders were very hard and very dry and somehow still just warm. The fries were delicious though. Somehow. Overkill in all the wrong places.
Carley (Cosmic Carleyy)
3 years agoThe burger tasted pretty good, nothing special. I was disappointed, the chicken tenders had too much breading in my opinion but the fries were delicious and such a great price! Highly recommend the vanilla milkshake. The chocolate version, however, tasted slightly off... I'm not quite sure how else to put it. Had some weird aftertaste for me. We were disappointed when the small vegan sandwich for $12 included no fries. We spent $52 for three meals and 2 shakes and an order of fries. Overall, more than I expected us to spend, and my mom didn't even order, but the fries and the aesthetically pleasing atmosphere helped.
Eric Kraley
Edited 2 years agoGreat food got the triple burger and onion rings they were the bomb. So I have to redo this because last week I got the LumberJack and Rings so good. Than for Veteran's Day I had to try their special which was very good. The red sauce was awesome love the burgers I will add to to see what new burger they come up with.
BigJayP
3 years agoLaker Larry Burger Onion rings Loaded fries Regular fries Great burger experience. Hand made fresh quality burgers and fries. The onion rings were really good except they were a little softer than I would have liked, but they still had great flavor. The fries and the loaded fries were both delicious. The Laker Larry Burger was excellent and just sloppy enough. Bring an appetite because they'll fill the void. The staff was attentive, super friendly, and treated you like you were the only person in the building. I told her I'd give her a shout out so here ya go... Anna has to be one of the friendliest, sweetest, most attentive, most talkative, cutest waitstaff I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. Thank you, Anna, for doing your job and doing it with panache. We'll be back to try some of the other delicious looking menu creations. Great job, Beefy's!
Candace D
Edited 3 years agoUsed to go there for the sandwich shop now today we went for the first time to try the beefy burger...great first impression! Nice service,great food,amazing shakes! And by reading other reviews before we went to try it ..they definitely listen to their customers...ketchup,mustard and paper towels at every table and station ,onion rings were not greasy! You will definitely leave there feeling full!
Jamie Turner
6 years agoAmazing. We ordered the reuban and the Italian. Very impressive and tasty. The ambiance was also delightful with a little beach like island feel to it. I almost changed my mind on take out as it's very inviting and colorful inside. The staff was great. They seemed to enjoy working there and though they were involved in conversation with each other, it wasnt distasteful or distracting. They still interacted with guests and each other and the food came out in a decent amount of time. I highly recommend stopping by and trying one of their sandwiches. Very satisfactory.
david deyoung
Edited 2 years agoService was quick. Ordering was easy, however we looked them up before arriving. Food truck pricing. The atmosphere was neat. Let's start with the onion rings, they were delicious, hand battered, and the burger sauce for dipping was spot on. They were greasy, and you'll probably 2nd guess that decision later. Then there was the burger. I got the single, I made it a deluxe, which added ketchup, mustard, mayo, tomato, lettuce, and choice of cheese, ( I added Swiss). I don't know if it was supposed to come with a pickle or not, but it was missing... The burger was good, single patty, a little sloppy, but not so sloppy my wife wouldn't be able to join me for lunch sloppy. Missing the pickle. Burger stayed together even after setting it down. Let's talk prices... $12-15 per person realistically with fries and drinks, which is fair; you could spend the same at the ol blue roof Wisconsin place for a similar but less adventurous meal without the experience. All in all, this place is worth the stop, and should be on the stop out to the lake, for sure! I'll be back to conquer one of the colossal burger options, but today, I was happy I didn't. Keep up the good work!